Soil seed bank under variegated thistle does not explain thistle dominance

  • Trevor K. James AgResearch
  • Katherine N. Tozer AgResearch
Keywords: Variegated thistle, Silybum marianum, soil seed bank


Variegated thistle (Silybum marianum) is a large, spiny annual that often forms dense monospecific communities on dry ridges and sunny hillslopes. The owner of a typical Poverty Bay hill-country farm with persistent variegated-thistle infestations reported that winter applications of herbicide were ineffectual in the long term as more variegated thistles simply recolonised the sprayed sites. An absence of preferred species, particularly perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) and legumes (Lotus and Trifolium spp.), in the soil seed bank under dense thistle populations may explain the persistence of these monospecific populations. To test this hypothesis, soil samples were collected from a dense and sparse variegated-thistle population in each of seven paddocks and incubated in a glasshouse. Emerged seedlings were identified and counted. The incubation was repeated three times. Total soil seed numbers were similar under both the dense and sparse populations with similar numbers of preferred legumes under both. However, there were significantly more perennial ryegrass seeds under the dense variegated-thistle populations compared with the sparse ones. Domination of thistles in densely infested patches was not due to lack of preferred species, or indeed other weed species, in the soil seed bank.


Chambreau D, MacLaren PA 2007 Got milk thistle? An adaptive management approach to eradicating milk thistle on dairies in King County, Washington State. In: Harrington TB, Reichard SH eds. Meeting the challenge: invasive plants in Pacific Northwest ecosystems PNW-GTR-694. United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station. Portland, Oregon, USA. Pp. 83–84.

Clifford PTP 1985. Effect of cultural practice on potential seed yield components of 'Grasslands Huia' and 'Grasslands Pitau' white clover. New Zealand Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 13: 301-306.

Dodd J 1989. Phenology and seed production of variegated thistle, Silybum marianum (L.) Gaertn., in Australia in relation to mechanical and biological control. Weed Research 29: 255–63.

Groves RH, Kaye PE 1989. Germination and phenology of seven introduced thistle species in southern Australia. Australian Journal of Botany 37: 351–359.

Hampton JG 1986. Effect of seed and seed lot 1000-seed weight on vegetative and reproductive yields of 'Grasslands Moata' tetraploid Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum). New Zealand Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 14: 13-18.

Howe CD, Chancellor RJ 1983. Factors affecting the viable seed content of soils beneath lowland pastures. Journal of Applied Ecology 20: 915–922.

Montemurro P, Fracchiolla M, Lonigro A 2007. Effects of some environmental factors on seed germination and spreading potentials of Silybum marianum Gaertner. Italian Journal of Agronomy 2: 315–320.

Rahman A, James T K Grbavac N, Mellsop J 1995. Evaluation of two methods for enumerating the soil weed seedbank. Proceedings of the New Zealand Plant Protection Conference 48: 175–180.

Roche C 1991. Milk thistle (Silybum marianum (L.) Gaertn.). Pacific Northwest Cooperative Extension Publication (PNW382).

Tozer KN, Barker GM, Cameron CA, James TK 2010. Relationship between seedbank and above-ground botanical composition during spring. New Zealand Plant Protection; 63: 90–95.

Young JA, Evans RA, Hawkes RB 1978. Milk thistle (Silybum marianum) seed germination. Weed Science 26: 395–398.
How to Cite
James, T., & Tozer, K. (2018). Soil seed bank under variegated thistle does not explain thistle dominance. New Zealand Plant Protection, 71, 51-56.
Vol 71 Weeds 2018

Most read articles by the same author(s)